Richard Lugar (R-Silence the Rabble) obviously thinks that bloggers need to be silenced:
Bloggers likely will not be deemed legitimate journalists who will be able to receive the coveted protections of a federal shield law, a key senator said Monday.
Sen. Richard Lugar, R-Ind., told a journalism conference that Web loggers may not qualify for that privilege, according to a report on Editor & Publisher's Web site. "As to who is a reporter, this will be a subject of debate as this bill goes farther along," Lugar said, according to the report. "Are bloggers journalists or some of the commercial businesses that you here would probably not consider real journalists? Probably not, but how do you determine who will be included in this bill?"
What does this mean?
There are a couple of forces at play here.
Atrios thinks that the act of blogging can be described as a form of journalism. Maybe.
The real question is, what constitutes a "journalist"?
Is it employment by a "certified" media outlet? How is that defined?
Is it NBC, or CNN or Fox? Is Gawker Media, which employs bloggers such as Wonkette a "certified" media outlet, and would Wonkette by extension be a journalist, and thus eligible for protection?
How about the Sports Illustrated columnist, who in Alabama was ruled not a journalist, because SI is a Magazine and not a Newspaper?
What about a Newspaper journalist who blogs? Is that persons blog not covered by a shield, but their work as a journalist is? Where does the journalist end and the blogger begin?
The position of Luger, and I suspect much of the mainstream media, is that people like me are pests, and the world would be a better place if we weren't placing a spotlight on the piss poor work that passes for journalism today.
The real fact is that if journalists, and newspapers, and news networks did their jobs, and reported the true facts, then there wouldn't be a necessity for this type of examination.
Now the media is doing the navel gazing, and they don't like what they see. The real problem is that they are not interested in changing. They don't want to change. Rather than change themselves, they want to change the rules.
Some politicians are on the change the rules bandwagon, because with the uncomfortable eye blogging has turned on the media, that eye is also on the politicians.